voya vs peers pe comparision
Here is how Voya's valuation compares to its peers, which directly quantifies the gap that activist investor TOMS Capital is pointing out -3-8.
📊 Valuation Comparison: Voya vs. Peers
| Metric | Voya (VOYA) | Peers / Industry | The Gap (Discount) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Forward P/E | 7.35x - 8.58x-1-2-4 | Sector Median: ~11.2x-2-5 | ~34% lower |
| Trailing P/E | ~12.1x-1-10 | Industry Average: ~17.3x-10 | ~30% lower |
| Price/Book (P/B) | ~1.6x-10 | Industry Average: ~3.0x-10 | ~47% lower |
Note: Some sources show a narrower gap vs. specific averages, but the consensus from financial data sites confirms a significant discount across all major metrics -7-9.
🏆 Stock Performance Comparison (YTD)
The market has recognized this gap, rewarding Voya's competitors more generously -3-6:
- Voya Financial: +9%
- Principal Financial Group: +17.5%
- Franklin Resources: +29.9%
🔍 What This Means for You
TOMS Capital argues that this gap is not due to poor operations (Voya has strong inflows and $1.1 trillion in AUM) -6-8.
Instead, they blame management's lack of strategic urgency-8. The data supports their case: the market is pricing Voya at a deep discount to peers because it lacks a clear plan to unlock value.
Would you like to see how Voya's profitability (ROE) compares to the industry standard?
Voya
Explore the complete collection of research questions, takeaways, and analyses in this board.